No. 25-95, October Term 2025. Decided, 9–0, opinion by Justice Alito.
Isabella County, Michigan, foreclosed on the Pung family home over $2,241.93 in unpaid property taxes and sold it at auction for $76,008, though it was assessed at $194,400. Michael Pung, for the estate, argued the Fifth Amendment's requirement of just compensation for taken property meant he should get the home's fair market value, and that the Eighth Amendment's ban on excessive fines applied. The Court took up both claims.
The Court held that after a fairly conducted tax sale, just compensation is measured by the auction price, not fair market value, and that the County did not violate the Excessive Fines Clause. It vacated the Sixth Circuit's judgment and sent the case back so that court can consider any properly preserved claims about unfair procedures. Justice Alito wrote for the Court, which was unanimous in the judgment, 9 to 0, with Justice Thomas joining all but Part II-B.
Page Proof 1. The proper Pending baseline for Publication measuring “just compensation” following a tax sale is the auction sale price, not the property's hypothetical fair market value, at least when the sale is fairly conducted in light of the country's history of tax sales.