Margolin v. NAIJ

No. 25-767, October Term 2025. Decided, 9–0, per curiam.

What the case is about (AI summary)

An association of immigration judges sued over a 2021 rule requiring supervisors to approve public speeches related to the judges' official duties, citing the First and Fifth Amendments. The trial court said the claims had to go through the review system set up by the Civil Service Reform Act. The Fourth Circuit sent the case back on a ground neither side had raised. The Court considered whether that broke the rule that courts decide only issues the parties present.

What the Court decided (AI summary)

The Court held that the Fourth Circuit violated the party-presentation principle, the rule that courts decide the arguments parties raise, by deciding a broader question than the judges' association had argued. In an unsigned opinion, the Court reversed the Fourth Circuit's judgment and sent the case back for further proceedings. The vote was 9 to 0. Justice Thomas, joined by Justice Barrett, wrote a concurrence.