No. 25-748, October Term 2025. Decided, 6–3, per curiam.
Pedro Hernandez was convicted in New York of kidnapping and murdering 6-year-old Etan Patz after confessing several times, including once before police read him his Miranda warnings. The jury asked whether it had to disregard his later confessions if it found the first one involuntary, and the judge said no. The Court took up whether federal law required a different answer, so that a federal court could overturn the conviction on habeas review (a prisoner's challenge to his detention).
In an unsigned opinion, the Court held 6 to 3 that the Second Circuit exceeded its authority in ordering habeas relief. No clearly established federal law required the trial judge to instruct the jury on whether an earlier confession tainted later ones. The Court reversed the Second Circuit's judgment and sent the case back for further proceedings. Justices Sotomayor, Kagan, and Jackson would have denied review.