No. 25-7026, October Term 2026. Granted, waiting for argument.
Federal law lets a prisoner appeal the denial of a habeas petition (a challenge to a conviction or sentence) only if a judge issues a "certificate of appealability." That requires a substantial showing that a constitutional right was denied, meaning reasonable judges could debate the outcome. The Court will decide whether a certificate should issue when binding precedent in the prisoner's own circuit rejects his claim but another circuit has accepted it.