Whitton v. Dixon

No. 25-580, October Term 2025. Decided, 7–2, per curiam.

What the case is about (AI summary)

Gary Whitton was convicted of murder in Florida and sentenced to death. At trial, a jailhouse informant testified that Whitton confessed, and falsely said he had no earlier criminal record. Whitton argued in a federal habeas petition (a challenge to a conviction as unlawful) that this violated his right to due process. The question was whether a federal appeals court could consider DNA evidence the jury never saw when judging if the false testimony mattered.

What the Court decided (AI summary)

In an unsigned opinion, the Court held that the Eleventh Circuit erred by considering DNA test results from after the trial. Evidence the jury never saw could not have affected its verdict, so it says nothing about whether the informant's testimony did. The Court vacated the judgment and sent the case back for the Eleventh Circuit to decide again using only the trial evidence. The vote was 7 to 2.