No. 25-52, October Term 2025. Decided, 9–0, per curiam.
A Maryland jury convicted Jeremiah Sweeney of second-degree murder after one juror visited the crime scene on his own. Sweeney asked a federal court for relief, claiming only that his lawyer was ineffective for not questioning the other jurors. The Fourth Circuit ordered a new trial on a different ground that Sweeney never raised. The Court took up whether that violated the rule that courts decide the claims the parties present.
In an unsigned opinion, the Court ruled unanimously, 9 to 0, that the Fourth Circuit departed so far from the party-presentation principle that it abused its discretion by granting relief on a claim Sweeney never made. The Court reversed the judgment and sent the case back so the Fourth Circuit can decide the ineffective-assistance claim Sweeney actually raised.