FCC v. AT&T

No. 25-406, October Term 2025. Decided, 8–1, opinion by Justice Roberts.

What the case is about (AI summary)

The Federal Communications Commission fined AT&T and Verizon for violations of the Communications Act. The companies paid and asked appeals courts to review the fines, arguing that the Seventh Amendment's right to a jury trial in lawsuits at common law required a jury before the agency could penalize them. The Fifth Circuit sided with AT&T and the Second Circuit rejected Verizon's claim, and the Supreme Court took up the question.

What the Court decided (AI summary)

The Court held that the FCC may issue forfeiture orders without a jury, because the orders do not by themselves require payment and the agency's factual findings are not binding. If the government sues to collect, the company gets a new jury trial. The Court reversed the Fifth Circuit in AT&T's case and affirmed the Second Circuit in Verizon's. Chief Justice Roberts wrote the opinion for the Court, which voted 8 to 1, with Justice Thomas dissenting.

Holding (syllabus)

Because forfeiture orders issued under § 503(b)(4) do not definitively resolve the parties' legal obligations, and the FCC's factual findings in its forfeiture proceedings are not conclusive, it does not violate the Seventh Amendment for the Commission to issue forfeiture orders without the involvement of a jury.