No. 24-993, October Term 2025. Decided, 9–0, opinion by Justice Kagan.
Gabriel Olivier, a street preacher, was arrested and fined under a Brandon, Mississippi ordinance that confines protesters near a public amphitheater to a designated area. He then sued the city in federal court under a civil rights law, 42 U.S.C. § 1983, asking only for a ruling that the ordinance violates the First Amendment's free speech protection and an order barring future enforcement. The question was whether the Court's decision in Heck v. Humphrey, which limits suits that challenge a past conviction, blocks his suit.
The Court held that Olivier's suit can go forward. Heck does not bar a suit that seeks only to stop future enforcement of a law, even when the person was previously convicted under it. Justice Kagan wrote for a unanimous Court, 9 to 0, reversing the Fifth Circuit and sending the case back for further proceedings.
Olivier's suit seeking purely prospective relief—an injunction stopping officials from enforcing an ordinance in the future—can proceed, notwithstanding Olivier's prior conviction for violating that ordinance; Heck does not hold otherwise.