No. 24-983, October Term 2025. Decided, 8–1, opinion by Justice Thomas.
A U.S. company, Havana Docks, held a time-limited right to run docks in Havana until Cuba's government seized them after 1959. Under a 1996 federal law, Americans with claims to property Cuba confiscated can sue anyone who "traffics" in it, meaning uses it without permission. Havana Docks sued four cruise lines that used the docks from 2016 to 2019. The Court took up whether the company must show the cruise lines used its expired property right or only the confiscated docks.
The Court held that using the confiscated docks is enough to show the cruise lines trafficked in "property which was confiscated"; Havana Docks need not show they used its own property interest, which would have expired in 2004. In an opinion by Justice Thomas, the Court voted 8 to 1 to vacate the Eleventh Circuit's ruling and send the case back for further proceedings. Justice Kagan dissented.
The cruise lines' use of the docks is sufficient to establish that they used “property which was confiscated by the Cuban Government”; Havana Docks is not required to establish that the cruise lines trafficked in Havana Docks' property interest.