No. 24-924, October Term 2025. Decided, 6–3, opinion by Justice Thomas.
A former Army soldier was badly hurt when a suicide bomber, who worked on a U.S. base in Afghanistan for a military contractor, attacked. He sued the contractor under South Carolina negligence law for how it supervised the bomber. The Court took up whether federal law, based on the government's immunity for wartime combat activities, blocks (preempts) state-law lawsuits against contractors.
The Court held that federal law did not block the soldier's state-law claims, because the government neither ordered nor authorized the contractor's challenged conduct. It vacated the Fourth Circuit's judgment and sent the case back for further proceedings. Justice Thomas wrote the opinion for the Court, 6 to 3.
The Fourth Circuit erred in finding Hencely's state-law tort claims preempted where the Federal Government neither ordered nor authorized Fluor's challenged conduct.