No. 24-872, October Term 2025. Decided, 5–4, per curiam.
Alabama wants to execute Joseph Smith, who was convicted of murder in 1998. Under Atkins v. Virginia, the Eighth Amendment's ban on cruel and unusual punishment bars executing a person with intellectual disability. Smith has taken five IQ tests, with scores from 72 to 78. The Court took up whether and how courts may weigh the combined effect of several IQ scores when deciding such a claim.
The Court dismissed the case as improvidently granted, meaning it ended review without deciding the IQ-score question. The ruling came in an unsigned opinion, by a vote of 5 to 4. The Eleventh Circuit's decision in Smith's favor stays in place. Justice Sotomayor, joined by Justice Jackson, concurred. Justices Thomas and Alito wrote dissents.