Rutherford v. United States

No. 24-820, October Term 2025. Decided, 6–3, opinion by Justice Barrett.

What the case is about (AI summary)

Two federal prisoners, Daniel Rutherford and Johnnie Carter, received long sentences for gun offenses before the First Step Act of 2018 cut the penalty for first-time offenders but did not apply it to people already sentenced. They asked courts to shorten their sentences under the compassionate-release law, which allows reductions for "extraordinary and compelling reasons." The Court took up whether that unequal treatment can count as such a reason.

What the Court decided (AI summary)

The Court held that when Congress chooses not to make a sentencing change retroactive, the resulting disparity cannot be an "extraordinary and compelling" reason for a sentence reduction. Justice Barrett wrote the opinion. It said a Sentencing Commission policy statement that says otherwise is invalid to that extent. The Court affirmed the Third Circuit's judgment, 6 to 3.

Holding (syllabus)

When Congress declines to make a sentencing amendment retroactive—as with the change to § 924(c)—the resulting sentencing disparity cannot serve as an “extraordinary and compelling” reason that warrants a sentence reduction under 18 U. S. C. § 3582(c)(1)(A)(i).