No. 24-781, October Term 2025. Decided, 9–0, opinion by Justice Gorsuch.
New Jersey's Attorney General served a subpoena on First Choice, a religious nonprofit pregnancy center, demanding documents including the names and contact details of most of its donors. First Choice sued in federal court, saying this violated its First Amendment right to associate freely with others. Lower courts held the claim was not yet ready for a federal court because no state court had ordered compliance. The Supreme Court considered whether the group had been harmed enough to sue.
The Court held that First Choice has shown a present injury to its First Amendment association rights, enough to give it standing to sue in federal court. Justice Gorsuch wrote for a unanimous Court that a demand for donor information can burden those rights while it is outstanding, without waiting for a state court order. The Court reversed the Third Circuit and sent the case back, 9 to 0.
First Choice has established a present injury to its First Amendment associational rights sufficient to confer Article III standing.