No. 24-777, October Term 2025. Decided, 9–0, opinion by Justice Jackson.
A husband, wife, and their child from El Salvador entered the United States without permission and asked for asylum, saying a hitman was targeting the husband. An immigration judge and the Board of Immigration Appeals found his testimony credible but ruled it did not show persecution, and the First Circuit agreed. The Court took up whether courts must defer to the Board when deciding if undisputed facts amount to "persecution" under immigration law.
The Court held that the Immigration and Nationality Act requires courts to apply the deferential substantial-evidence standard to the agency's decision on whether undisputed facts amount to persecution. Under that standard, a court may overturn the decision only if any reasonable adjudicator would be compelled to reach the opposite conclusion. The Court affirmed the First Circuit unanimously, 9 to 0, in an opinion by Justice Jackson.
The INA requires application of the substantial-evidence standard to the agency's determination whether a given set of undisputed facts rises to the level of persecution under § 1101(a)(42)(A).