No. 24-7351, October Term 2025. Decided, 5–4, opinion by Justice Kavanaugh.
Terry Pitchford, convicted of capital murder and sentenced to death in Mississippi for a 2004 grocery store robbery, argues prosecutors struck four of five Black potential jurors because of race. The Equal Protection Clause bars race-based jury strikes under Batson v. Kentucky. The Court considered whether the Mississippi Supreme Court unreasonably found that Pitchford waived his chance to rebut the prosecutor's race-neutral explanations, under the federal habeas law, AEDPA.
The Court held that the Mississippi Supreme Court unreasonably applied Batson and unreasonably found that Pitchford waived his chance to argue the prosecutor's reasons were a pretext, meaning a cover for race. The trial judge cut off defense counsel and said the objection was preserved. In an opinion by Justice Kavanaugh, the Court voted 5 to 4 to reverse the Fifth Circuit and send the case back.
The Mississippi Supreme Court unreasonably applied the clearly established Batson precedents and unreasonably determined that Pitchford waived his opportunity to rebut the prosecutor's asserted raceneutral reasons for the peremptory strikes of four black prospective jurors.