No. 24-557, October Term 2025. Decided, 9–0, opinion by Justice Jackson.
David Villarreal was on trial for murder in Texas. While he was testifying, the judge ordered a 24-hour overnight break and told his lawyers not to "manage his testimony," though they could still discuss other matters like sentencing. The Court took up whether that order violated the Sixth Amendment's guarantee of the right to a lawyer.
The Court held that an order barring only discussion of the defendant's testimony for its own sake during an overnight break in his testimony does not violate the Sixth Amendment. Justice Jackson wrote the opinion for the Court. The vote was 9 to 0, with Justice Thomas, joined by Justice Gorsuch, agreeing only in the result. The Court affirmed the Texas Court of Criminal Appeals.
A qualified conferral order that prohibits only discussion of the defendant's testimony for its own sake during a midtestimony overnight recess permissibly balances the defendant's Sixth Amendment right to counsel against the burden of offering unaltered trial testimony and does not violate the Constitution.