No. 24-556, October Term 2025. Decided, 8–1, opinion by Justice Barrett.
Joe Fernandez was convicted of murder for hire and received life sentences. After losing his appeals and earlier challenges, he asked a federal judge for compassionate release, a statute allowing reduced sentences for "extraordinary and compelling reasons," arguing mainly that he was innocent. The Court took up whether reasons that could also be used to challenge a conviction under the separate postconviction statute, 28 U.S.C. § 2255, can count for compassionate release.
The Court held that a prisoner challenging the validity of his conviction must use § 2255, and that a conviction's supposed invalidity is not an "extraordinary and compelling reason" for compassionate release. Justice Barrett wrote the opinion for the Court, which affirmed the Second Circuit's ruling. The vote was 8 to 1, with Justice Sotomayor, joined by Justice Kagan, concurring only in the judgment and Justice Jackson dissenting.
A prisoner who collaterally attacks the validity of his conviction must proceed through 28 U. S. C. § 2255, not 18 U. S. C. § 3582; the supposed invalidity of a conviction is not among the “extraordinary and compelling reasons” that justify compassionate release.