Fernandez v. United States

No. 24-556, October Term 2025. Decided, 8–1, opinion by Justice Barrett.

What the case is about (AI summary)

Joe Fernandez was convicted of murder for hire and received life sentences. After losing his appeals and earlier challenges, he asked a federal judge for compassionate release, a statute allowing reduced sentences for "extraordinary and compelling reasons," arguing mainly that he was innocent. The Court took up whether reasons that could also be used to challenge a conviction under the separate postconviction statute, 28 U.S.C. § 2255, can count for compassionate release.

What the Court decided (AI summary)

The Court held that a prisoner challenging the validity of his conviction must use § 2255, and that a conviction's supposed invalidity is not an "extraordinary and compelling reason" for compassionate release. Justice Barrett wrote the opinion for the Court, which affirmed the Second Circuit's ruling. The vote was 8 to 1, with Justice Sotomayor, joined by Justice Kagan, concurring only in the judgment and Justice Jackson dissenting.

Holding (syllabus)

A prisoner who collaterally attacks the validity of his conviction must proceed through 28 U. S. C. § 2255, not 18 U. S. C. § 3582; the supposed invalidity of a conviction is not among the “extraordinary and compelling reasons” that justify compassionate release.