No. 24-351, October Term 2025. Decided, 5–4, opinion by Justice Thomas.
Lebene Konan, a Texas landlord, says Postal Service employees in Euless intentionally withheld mail meant for her and her tenants at two rental properties, and she sued the United States for damages under state tort law. A federal law lets people sue the government for employees' wrongs but keeps immunity for claims arising from the "loss" or "miscarriage" of mail. The question is whether that exception covers deliberate nondelivery.
The Court held that the United States keeps its immunity from claims based on intentional nondelivery of mail, because "miscarriage" and "loss" of mail can result from deliberate acts. Justice Thomas wrote for a 5 to 4 Court. The Court vacated the Fifth Circuit's ruling and sent the case back, without deciding whether all of Konan's claims are barred.
The United States retains sovereign immunity for claims arising out of the intentional nondelivery of mail because both “miscarriage” and “loss” of mail under the FTCA’s postal exception can occur as a result of the Postal Service’s intentional failure to deliver the mail.