Hunter v. United States

No. 24-1063, October Term 2025. Decided, 8–1, opinion by Justice Kagan.

What the case is about (AI summary)

Hunter pleaded guilty in federal court and signed a plea agreement giving up his right to appeal his sentence. He then tried to appeal a condition requiring him to take mental health medication, citing his due process rights, and noted the judge told him he could appeal. The Fifth Circuit dismissed the appeal, allowing only two exceptions to such waivers. The Supreme Court took up when, if ever, an appeal waiver cannot be enforced.

What the Court decided (AI summary)

An agreement not to appeal a sentence is unenforceable when enforcing it would be a miscarriage of justice, meaning it would leave in place an egregious error that would bring the judicial system into disrepute. The Court held 8 to 1, in an opinion by Justice Kagan, that the judge's misstatement and the government's silence did not cancel Hunter's waiver. It vacated the Fifth Circuit's judgment and sent the case back for that court to apply the standard.

Holding (syllabus)

An agreement not to appeal a sentence is unenforceable when it would result in a miscarriage of justice—meaning, when it would leave in place the kind of egregious error that would bring the judicial system into disrepute.